The Magazine

After 250 Years, It’s Time to Rethink the Story of the “United States”

A line of protesters stands along a sidewalk facing a large group of uniformed law enforcement officers. Some protesters hold signs and a flag of the "United States", while others wear high-visibility vests and winter clothing. The officers, dressed in tactical gear, stand in formation across the roadway.
Hundreds of protesters gathered outside the Whipple Federal Building near Fort Snelling following the fatal shooting of Renee Good by an ICE agent. Journalist Rebecca Nagle photographed the protest while reporting for First America. Photo credit: Rebecca Nagle, January 8, 2026.

For 250 years, the story of the “United States” has been told largely without Native people at the center of it. But what if leaving them out means we have misunderstood the history itself?

That is the question at the heart of First America, a six-part narrative podcast produced and hosted by award-winning Cherokee journalist Rebecca Nagle. The podcast examines how Native nations, their sovereignty, and their resistance shaped the country from its founding—and how its history of colonization continues to shape the country’s politics, government, and policies today.

For The Magazine, we spoke with Nagle about reclamation, the responsibility of telling stories that have been erased or distorted, and why understanding Indigenous history is essential not only for Native people, but for anyone trying to understand the “United States.”

First America is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Amazon Music.

When you hear the word reclamation, what does it mean to you personally?

Oh, that’s a really good question. As Indigenous people, a lot has been taken from us. Material things, like land, but also through the suppression of languages, religion, and culture, and their appropriation. We’ve also lost a lot of that because of colonialism. So when I think about reclamation, I think about taking back those things that have been taken from us. And also, as a journalist, I think about creating spaces where we get to set our own narratives and tell our own stories.

You reported and produced First America. For someone who hasn’t heard it yet, what is the podcast about, and how did the project come together?

First America is about the origin story of the “United States.” Most often, when that story is told, Native people are missing. We’re just completely left out. And without us, it’s not that the story’s a little inaccurate or incomplete; it’s actually wrong. Americans actually don’t know their own country, and the podcast argues that. We don’t know how America got to where it is today, and we don’t understand that, because we actually don’t know how it started and where it came from. From the real reasons for the Revolution, to the text of the Declaration of Independence, to the Boston Tea Party, to the Revolutionary War itself, to the creation of the military, to what kind of government our founders created, [history] is actually incomplete. The podcast goes into those topics and really helps people see that Native history isn’t something that impacts Native people or Tribes. It is foundational to why the “U.S.” is the way that it is, and how this affects everybody in “North America.”

Media and press freedoms are globally under attack and severely underfunded

Help us in our mission to create Indigenous led journalism and media content. We are the only free Indigenous created and operated independent international publication that runs in English and Spanish and that is committed to disability and language justice.

You’ve talked about how putting Native history back into the story of the “United States” changes the way we understand the country. What does reclaiming that history mean for the future of Native people living in what is now the “United States?”

I really believe that we will not understand the government of the “United States,” and particularly the present rise in authoritarianism, if we don’t understand what our government did to Native people. One of the biggest myths in the “U.S.” is this idea that our founders built a democracy. We have versions [of history] where the democracy was very flawed; it didn’t include everybody, but at its heart, it was a democratic form of government, and generations of Americans have built upon that foundation and made it better.

What that story leaves out is the history of “U.S.” colonialism and empire. At the same time our founders were building a democracy, they were also building a part of the “U.S.” government that didn’t govern through elections and representation but governed through force, through top-down, authoritarian forms of government. So what we’re seeing today in our current political crisis isn’t new to the “United States;” it’s always been part of who we are as a country.

Why is that understanding important for our future? We can’t root out authoritarianism if we don’t understand where it came from. People think that it’s [because of] a specific political party, or even one political leader, but the roots of it are much deeper than that. So if we think we can defeat it in one election, it’ll be like chopping off the head of a weed: it’ll only grow back stronger. If we really want to root [authoritarianism] out, we have to get down to the beginning and the root of it.

Why do you think people often see colonization as something that happened in the past, rather than as an ongoing process? And what are the dangers or consequences of viewing it that way?

One thing is that the government that colonized Indigenous land, dispossessed Indigenous people, put them in concentration camps, organized death marches, sometimes committed mass executions and mass slaughters, and sent children to boarding schools, implemented all of those policies. That government is still our government. In a democratic society, we really shouldn’t have a government that can round up an entire ethnic group and put them in detention. [We have] to make sure that our government is never capable of that. But as Americans, we’ve never had that moment. What you’ve seen is that instead, some of these policies that were first used against Indigenous people have been applied to other groups of people.

One specific example is during World War II, when our government had Japanese concentration or internment camps. The first camps were placed on reservations and were run by the Bureau of Indian Affairs because that department knew how to detain people, how to detain people intergenerationally, how to keep families confined, and had the technology to do that. They even used some of the same doctors from reservation hospitals.

You can see the trajectory of these policies: first to dispossess Indigenous people, but then it got applied to places like Guam and Puerto Rico. Eventually, it got applied to immigration. These tools of our government, which I think most people would agree a democratic government shouldn’t be able to use, are things we’ve allowed our government to do over and over again. It’s just done to groups of people we don’t often talk about.

In many ways, would you say our current political moment is 250 years in the making?

That’s the tagline of the podcast, so I agree. One example is the war on Iran, bombing boats in the Caribbean Sea, and the invasion of Venezuela. There’s been a lot of talk about what kind of power the president has to fight conflict without Congressional approval, with some people saying Trump shouldn’t be able to do [all] this without Congressional oversight. But actually, the first undeclared wars go back to the George Washington administration, and a lot of experts think that the first undeclared war was actually with Indigenous nations and the Northwest Confederacy, as an effort to expand and to take more Indigenous land. What we’re seeing is this dynamic of feeling like a president has more power than it should have, that we’re uncomfortable with, and that power [dynamic] goes back to wars with Indigenous Nations.

White, purple, yellow, and pink flowers are arranged on the snow at a memorial where Renee Good was fatally shot by an ICE agent in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The memorial includes bouquets and individual flowers left in her memory.
Flowers are placed at the site in Minneapolis, Minnesota, where Renee Good was fatally shot by an ICE agent. Journalist Rebecca Nagle was in Minneapolis reporting for First America when Good was killed. Photo credit: Rebecca Nagle, January 7, 2026.

How has that shaped the way Americans—both Indigenous and non-Indigenous—understand history today, and how has it influenced contemporary politics, law, and public policy?

So not having those [Indigenous] voices is not having that perspective. When I first started this project in collaboration with some Indigenous scholars—Ned Blackhawk, Maggie Blackhawk, Phil Deloria, and Nick Estes—we all talked about being frustrated with how Native people are consistently left out of the American story, whether it’s in textbooks, news coverage, or pop culture versions of history. We had a similar frustration. That’s where the project started: wanting to get more Americans to know the Native part of the history, and to put Native people back into the American story. The further I got into the reporting, I realized that what people were missing wasn’t just Indigenous people or me and my community, but it was actually the truth about America itself. When you get into the history, we’re omnipresent in the founders’ lives. They’re meeting with Indigenous leaders; they’re debating what to do; we’re influencing culture and what people think of what it means to be American. It’s just been this active erasure that has come later that has left us with this incomplete story.

Is there anything that surprised you during your journey reporting and working on First America?

The biggest thing was how much of the history is right there at the surface, but we don’t talk about it. [For example], we tell the story of the American Revolution as if it was fought over taxation and representation. But when you read the Declaration of Independence, there’s this other reason that our founders were angry at the King of England. We learn about the Declaration of Independence as the preamble that all men are created equal, but when you read the document, many historians think the list of complaints has an order: it starts with smaller things and crescendos with the biggest ones. The last grievance is about “merciless Indian savages,” in their own words.

Our founders are saying this is the thing England has betrayed us the most about. The colonists wanted to keep expanding west during the Revolutionary War; the land of “North America” was theirs for the taking. But England didn’t want to fight wars with Indigenous Nations, and when settlers squatted on Indigenous land, it would often lead to war. So the King of England made peace with Indigenous Nations and told settlers they couldn’t move west past the Appalachian Mountains. That basic dynamic of settlers and colonists wanting more land and England saying no was one of the biggest drivers of the Revolutionary War itself. This is not hidden; it’s not some secret; it’s right there in the Declaration of Independence. For me, what was surprising was how much it’s there. I think it’s just really surprising how close to the surface this history is. It’s almost like it’s hiding in plain sight.

What responsibilities come with telling stories that have been historically ignored, distorted, or told by a colonizer or an outsider?

One is that I feel an immense amount of responsibility to get the story right, because so often, the way Native history and Native stories are told is inaccurate. That inaccuracy causes a lot of harm. If you’re gonna help create that footprint, it’s important that footprint is correct. And then I try to work with Tribes and with Tribal leaders to make sure that we’re getting the information right, and that we’re telling the story in a way that feels representative.

What kind of emotional weight does that carry, especially when you’re also talking about getting the story right?

I will say that it is very emotional. There are some really hard subjects in the podcast, including the violence against Indigenous people during the Revolutionary War. The evidence is so overwhelming; [on the podcast] we make the argument that during the Revolutionary War, the “U.S.” committed genocide against Indigenous people, and those stories of that violence and that suffering are really heavy. I try to create space to process those hard feelings; I let them come up when they need to. I try to bring those emotions into the writing and what the audience and the listeners experience. Because I think it is really important that we feel this history, and part of reckoning with the violent history of this country is feeling it, right?

Has this reporting changed your view of your identity or your Indigenous community?

I see the role of Native history in the “United States” has shifted. For a long time, I had this frustration with erasure and with how Native people were always left out of the story [because] it creates this stubborn stereotype in non-Native people’s minds that you don’t exist. But in doing this reporting, I realized Non-native people are harmed by that erasure too because they don’t actually see their own country and their own government accurately and clearly. And you can’t fix something if you don’t understand what it is.

What gives you hope when you think about the future of Indigenous communities?

The thing that gives me the most hope is really young people. Whenever I’m interacting with Indigenous young people, particularly young adults, I’m just so impressed with their understanding of the world, their understanding of politics, their vision for the future. I would say that’s probably more than anything what gives me hope for the future.

Ready to learn about the story the real story of the “United States”? Don’t miss First America. Listen to this podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Amazon Music.

Editorial note: This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity and length.

Media and press freedoms are globally under attack and severely underfunded

Help us in our mission to create Indigenous led journalism and media content. We are the only free Indigenous created and operated independent international publication that runs in English and Spanish and that is committed to disability and language justice.

 Our work crosses borders, oceans, languages, disabilities, digital divides, and prison walls. Your donation is essential to continuing our work.